Ask most restaurant operators what their delivery strategy is and they will describe their DoorDash setup, their Uber Eats ads, or their Grubhub commission rate.
That is a platform strategy. It is not a delivery strategy.
A real delivery strategy accounts for where you want those customers ordering from in 12 months, 24 months, and beyond. For most multi-location restaurant groups, the answer is increasingly: directly.
What Third-Party Platforms Are Actually Good For
Third-party delivery platforms — DoorDash, Uber Eats, and Grubhub — do specific things extremely well that no first-party channel can replicate at the same scale.
Discovery
When someone opens DoorDash in an unfamiliar neighborhood or wants to try something new, you want to be there. Third-party apps are powerful discovery engines.
Logistics
Building your own delivery fleet is expensive, operationally complex, and rarely makes sense below significant order volume. Third-party platforms provide an outsourced logistics network most restaurants cannot replicate cost-effectively.
Speed to market
For a new location, getting live on DoorDash can take days. Building a functional first-party ordering and delivery system can take much longer.
These are genuine advantages. Third-party platforms belong in every delivery strategy — as a discovery and new customer acquisition channel.
What Third-Party Platforms Are Terrible For
What platforms are not good for: owning the customer relationship, keeping margin, building loyalty, and giving you data.
When a customer orders through DoorDash, DoorDash owns that transaction. They have the customer’s name, order history, and contact information. You get an order and a payout. If that customer’s next order goes to a competitor because DoorDash showed them a sponsored listing, you may never know.
The margin issue
At scale, commission, processing fees, marketing fees, and promo costs can turn third-party delivery into a high-volume but low-margin channel. The more repeat customers stay trapped there, the more expensive the channel becomes.
What First-Party Ordering Actually Looks Like
A first-party ordering channel is your restaurant’s own digital storefront — accessible through your website, a mobile app, or a QR code — where customers can order directly without going through DoorDash or Uber Eats.
Platforms like Toast can handle ordering infrastructure, payment processing, and in some cases delivery logistics through integrations, often at a flat per-order fee instead of a percentage commission.
Operational advantages
- You own the customer data — email, phone, and order history.
- You control the ordering experience — no competitor ads and no algorithm suppressing your placement.
- You can run loyalty programs that actually build repeat behavior.
- Your menu changes can sync more cleanly from your POS.
- You can build direct remarketing and retention campaigns over time.
The Right Model: Both Channels, Different Jobs
The mistake most operators make is treating this as either/or. It is not.
Use third-party for:
- New customer discovery
- Marketplace visibility
- Geographic reach
- Launch momentum
- Incremental demand during strategic windows
Use first-party for:
- Repeat customers
- Loyalty and retention
- Higher-margin ordering
- Customer data ownership
- Long-term brand relationship building
The right delivery strategy lets third-party platforms introduce customers to the restaurant, then gradually gives those customers reasons to order directly.
How to Start Shifting Customers Direct
You do not need to abandon third-party platforms to build a first-party strategy. Start with simple, operator-safe steps:
- Add branded insert cards to delivery bags that promote direct ordering for the next purchase.
- Use QR codes in-store and on packaging that point to your direct ordering page.
- Create loyalty incentives that only apply to direct orders.
- Promote direct ordering on social, Google Business Profile, and your website.
- Use third-party delivery to acquire new customers, then use first-party ordering to retain them.
Final takeaway
Third-party platforms are useful. They are not the whole strategy. The operators building durable, high-margin delivery businesses use marketplaces for discovery and owned channels for retention.
More Resources
Keep exploring practical ways to improve delivery platform performance, margin, and visibility.